Bryan Derballa
Brooklyn-based photographer, Bryan Derballa has taken photos for The Wall Street Journal, Rolling Stone, Vice, The Financial Times.
http://lovebryan.com/bryan/
Questions for Mr. Derballa mostly focused on the role of photography in the news and telling a story with an image.
Nodoka described her reaction to Mr. Derballa's response in this way:
"He does not believe that photos alone can accurately portray the news,but
he thinks they have a visceral and emotional power that words often
lack. I used to think photo journalist believe that photos tell
everything and they are so eager to take photos that have strong image.
He thinks seeking the truth is the most important. I respect this
behavior. However, I felt he has passion to be a photo journalist. He
appreciate a photo with strong content captured with a sense of
artistry. He said there are so many factors including
timing, light, composition, movement, distance, relevance, color, emotion
and so much more. He claimed that: 'No photo will have everything,but
some get close. Every photo I love is for a different reason.' I really
moved this response and understood how much he loves photos."
Masayoshi also added: "In addition, he told that one of his favorite things to see in photos is
metaphor, and he explained how photography functions as a visual
language and can produce complex ideas and powerful emotions. I
surprised his deep insight and understanded how to enjoy seeing a
photos. Next time I see a picture, I will try to see carefully."
Eszter Farkas
Now in Budapest, Eszter Farkas wrote for the German wire service, Deutsche Presse Agentur (DPA) in Ghana, covering West Africa.
https://twitter.com/farkas_e
So wrote of the interview with Ms. Farkas:
"Her news chief
once said that whenever he had to decide whether a piece of information was
news or not, he posed the question: 'would my mother care to read about
it?' I was so surprised to hear this story. It's true that journalist should
pursue justice, but they must also forget the news that nobody gets interested
in and reading in meaningless."
"It's very difficult problem. When journalists decide whether an information is news or not, they should care about contents and readers. If they care about readers rather than contents, news story can probably become something like a 'low' weekly magazine."
In
light of this, he noted that there is a need for balance.
Ichiro was interested in Ms. Farkas' motivation to become a journalist:
"The questions
that I asked Ms. Farkas were why did she choose to become a journalist, and
what is the best thing about journalism. I asked these questions because, to be
very honest, I wasn’t interested in Journalism. So I wanted to know what is the
attraction or fascination of journalism. Her answer to the former question
motivated me a lot. She says she didn’t have a specific dream at the age of
mine. But she made an action. She started to work in her field while attending
classes, and as a result it was her beginning of her career. I don’t have a
specific dream right now. But I feel like I should make an action, instead of
just waiting for the moment that I find my dream. Her answer to the latter
question, she says the good thing is the contribution to people’s better
understanding and the role is not only transmit the news, but also give voice
to those who are generally underrepresented or oppressed. Journalists might
have some power to change the world. I never knew this big role of journalist
before I take this class. Ms. Farkas and this
class changed my perspective on journalism a lot."
Derek Henry Flood
Derek Flood has
covered
conflicts in Georgia, Mali, Syria, Libya, Bahrain, Kyrgyzstan, Kurdistan,
Kashmir, Afghanistan, Iraq and Lebanon. He has appeared on CNN, France 24, BBC World
Service, BBC Arabic television, and Voice of America as an international
affairs contributor.
https://twitter.com/DerekHenryFlood
http://the-war-diaries.com/
Toru was
interested in the issue of going to dangerous areas to collect news: "I
thought IWhy they go to a dangerous area?' I heard that Mr.Derek often go to a dangerous area to interview
as freelance journalist, so I decided to ask him."
Ichiro also noted his curiosity about working in a conflict zone:
"
I got interested
Mr. Flood because I was always wondering how the journalists in the conflict
zones work and feel about the issue. The people’s life in the conflict zones
are geographically and psychologically very far from us. I have never felt fear
or danger when I sleep. I cannot even imagine what the people in the conflict
zones feel and think. I thought the role of those journalist was very big and
responsible."
Toru linked this experience to current events in now: "Among
these answers and reactions [from the journalists], what I thought it was interesting was about self-protection that I
asked Mr. Flood. Now two Japanese are captured by ISIS. I do not intend to say
they neglected self-protection. However, when you go to a dangerous area, no
matter how you are cautious, you can never be too cautious. I think Japanese
freelance journalists should learn from Mr.Derek."
Ichiro noted how interviewing Mr. Flood also led him to new conclusions about current events: "The questions I
asked Mr. Flood were what does he feel when he sees war or conflict, doesn’t he
feel fear when he is in dangerous situation, and what makes him relaxed when he
feels afraid or stressed out. I thought the first question was very deep. I
thought I could get a response that indicate why he has chosen the career and
maybe he has very strong opinion about the issue. I asked the rest of question
because I just wanted to know how the people in danger feel.
His answer to my
question was very to the point, and I totally agreed with his opinion. He
says self-sustaining cycles of violence are much easier to foment than to
break. I think not only the conflict in the Middle East, but in everywhere this
problem could be found. Reading his great answer, I noticed the weakness of
human. Since I followed Isis, I thought I knew much about the issue. I thought
only destroying them would be a solution, but as he says the real solution would
be that one must go there, talk and make them understand the whole situation
rather than providing the violence, to prevent violence-cycle. To the question
about fear or stress, he says the books, DVDs, humor and love makes him
relaxed. These are the stuffs that also make me feel relaxed when I get
stressed out. He is a very great guy, but I felt kind of close to him. His
answers were very deep and gave me different perspective. It was very great to
interview him."
Takumi noted that in interviewing Mr. Flood, who first became involved in journalism after experiencing 9/11 in NYC, he reflected on his own position as an observer of historical events:
"In first
question's answer, he touched on 9.11. Indeed, it connected chain of events in
Afhganistan, Iraq and Syria today. I believe I am also a witness crucial
event. Especially, 3.11and Fukushima problem. This accident is element enough to
think about society, and to begin more studying .If I am not to be a journalist, I
make effort more than ever before."
Martina Kix
Martina Kix is an editor for Neon Magazine, and a former editor for Vice Magazine in Germany.
https://twitter.com/martinakix
https://twitter.com/neon_magazin
Hayato noted that: "I was impressed by her thought that minority group's voice is very important.
I can clearly
find the existence of minority stream.
I got to think we should choose topics and discuss about variety of streams.
I got to think we should choose topics and discuss about variety of streams.
She also
know about Japanese culture and news very well.
I got to
know what these people who is in other countries think about current events in Japan."
From his interview with Ms. Kix, Hayato came to feel: "I
strongly got to want to know the news using a lot of sources and points of
view. Prejudice
is not good for knowing news, and we should always think about that."
Overall, the chance to interview journalists via email, and have Mr. Sawa come and visit the class, left us with a deeper understanding about the people behind the news we read.
Nodoka: "Through this interview, I realized journalists were so careful to tell
news stories. They must not write uncertain articles. I used to think
journalist's works are machine-like, but I realized that was wrong."
Masayoshi: "I have read news papers for a long time, but I have never think about
the journalists,and I have not read carefully and think about the
contents of the articles deeply. In this class, I can get the
opportunity to know about the journalists, and I know journalists take
efforts to express the news better. Now, I attempt to know what the
journalist try to express when I read and watch the news.
I still have one question. What should I do to understand what the journalist want to express accurately?"
I still have one question. What should I do to understand what the journalist want to express accurately?"
Ichiro: "Through asking these journalists and taking
this class, I noticed that there is actually a person who struggled to get
information and truth. When I read the news before, I only read the fact, but
now I unconsciously read the story. Also I noticed that the journalists connect
big news with our ordinary life to make us interested in."
"My impressive things
in this class is the class by Sawa-san. This is because, he helped me to
understand about making news. I think I can hear just an interesting story at
first time. However the accident happened that French media was attacked.Their
mood in the press caused this tragedy. All news is made by human. Therefore,we
have to pay attenstion some human who make the news, and receive the news."
Takumi ended by remarking that: "You are also one of those behind the news, aren't you?"
Mr.Derballa is very interesting for me among these journalists without I interviewed. I understand that photo suggests some situations and has very important part from Nodoka and Takumi's report. Photos has a lot of hidden words and idea, so I will try to understand these hidden things hard.
ReplyDeleteI think that our classmates has diversity of perspectives. Their questions that they asked journalists are very interested and empathetic. They have a great point of view that I don't have. And, I think they can not only grasp surface of events but also background of events. They often stated their own opinions toward a event occurred around the world, these opinions always made me understand. I think that these reports are unique, so if we had next class, we could discuss these things. However we can't, I feel very disappointed.
Reading the reaction to Mr. Derballa, I noticed the importance and functions of photos. Photos by themselves may not describe the whole issue, but they could be more powerful and influential than words.
ReplyDeleteReading the reaction to Ms. Farkas, I felt the same way with So. I never knew that journalists not only transmit the facts, but also make news that interests us. Knowing that they make stories which make us feel involved and interested in was surprising for me too.
Reading the reaction to Flood, I thought Toru's viewpoint was interesting. Since two Japanese people were captured and beheaded by Isis, I want not only Japanese but also every journalists to be very cautious.
After finishing reading all these reactions, I guess we all realized the roles of journalists are not only transmitting the fact and pursuing the justice, but also giving a voice to minority people which is perhaps the key to change the world. Also since we actually saw behind the news: how the news is made, what journalists really think, how they work and so on, I'm sure that this class gave us a chance to think about news deeply
In the reaction to Mr.Derballa’s response, Nodoka’s response is the same as mine. I did not know the attraction about photo,but after reading his response, I understand the attraction easily because he explained it in detail. In addition, I could feel his passion for taking photos.
ReplyDeleteIn this class, I knew that journalist s have a variety of ideas about their work , and take efforts to express the news better. I noticed that their passions for their jobs are not different from our passions for our favorite things. this is an ordinary thing, but I have forgot this simple fact and thought journalists were machine-like because In Japan, there were a lot of troubles that journalists caused.
In this class, I could understand about the people behind the news we read and get the opportunity to listen to other classmates opinions. As a result, I thought I could get new way to think.
I realize that journalism is very difficult.
ReplyDeleteJournalists have a important role of giving a lot of information to us by writing article or taking a picture. It's no exaggeration to say that we could not live if all journalists passed away because we cannot make a decision without any information.
However, journalists are always in danger.
For example, journalist, like Mr. Flood, need to go to dangerous area in order to interview the people living in conflict area like Middle East. Though they take a risk in order to get information, if they are killed like Mr. Goto, he become a target of criticism.
Journalists have a large responsibility. I can guess under this situation, they always make a news story while feeling struggle. I think when we read newspaper or something like magazine, I would like to understand the emotion behide the news story.
I’m surprised at the depth of journalism.
ReplyDeleteEvery journalists have their belief.
Related to the current ISIS happening, I was wondering why there are people want to go such a dangerous areas.
So in the reaction to Mr.Flood, Ichiro and Toru’s notice is interesting for me.
I haven’t known the freerances’ who are going to dangerous areas motivation.
However, I believe I got to know the mind of freerance journalists thanks for them.
In conclusion, I strongly think one of the most important aspects of knowing news is to know what the journalists think.
I was moved to hear passions of journalists through this interview. After finishing this class however, the ISIS problem bacame serious. Japanese journalist went into the dangerous place even he was at risk and was killed . I was really shocked and came to wonder that why they are so eager to know the truth.We have already talked about ISIS,but no one may thought that Japanese will be improved.I wanted to talk about this news with my classmates and also ask this problem to journalists. Will they agree to his act? l wonder.
ReplyDeleteAnyway, I appreciate professor Schieder to giving us good oppotunity to think deeply about the news and its behind.